A peasant fires on federal soldiers to save his home. Therefore the Mexican Revolution swallows him whole, turning a farmer into a legend then leaving him dead in the very canyon where it began.

Why this book

Published in 1915 while the fighting still raged, it became the first great novel of the Mexican Revolution, the book that taught Latin America how war truly looks from the ground, seen through the eyes of the men who bleed for it, not the generals who plan it from maps.

The Story

Demetrio Macias, a poor farmer in the mountains of Zacatecas, hides his wife and child as federal soldiers ransack his home hunting him. He wounds one in the scuffle, therefore he knows they will return with more guns, so that night he flees into the hills.

In the sierra he gathers other wronged peasants, Anastasio, Pancracio, the boy nicknamed Quail, men with raw courage but no training, farmers holding rifles they barely know how to fire, bound together only by shared grievance against the regime that burned their homes and fields.

Luis Cervantes, a federal army medical student, deserts after his own officers humiliate him in front of the ranks. Therefore he seeks out Demetrio's band and talks his way in, offering to explain the Cause to illiterate men who have never once heard the word spoken aloud.

Demetrio distrusts this soft-handed city man among his ranch hands, but Cervantes proves useful, dressing wounds, and dressing the revolution itself in words the men repeat without fully understanding. Therefore Demetrio lets him stay, uneasy but curious what use he might still prove.

Word arrives that Pancho Villa's forces are massing nearby, gathering every scattered band under one banner. Demetrio's men join them, therefore what began as one farmer defending his doorway becomes a single current inside a war now sweeping the whole country.

At the assault on Zacatecas, Demetrio leads a charge straight up the fortified hillside under withering fire; bullets cut men down on both sides, but his ragged band breaks the federal line, and by nightfall the city, and its garrison, have fallen.

Victory turns quickly to plunder. Demetrio's men strip the federal dead and loot the wealthy houses, drinking captured wine straight from crystal decanters, therefore soldiers who once owned nothing now ride other men's horses wearing other men's stolen coats.

Camila, a village girl, nurses the wounded Cervantes back to health and falls for him honestly, without calculation. He charms her with soft, practiced words, but his interest is only amusement, therefore he strings her along with no intention of ever staying.

Meanwhile La Pintada, a fierce camp follower long attached to Demetrio's band, watches Camila with open contempt, jealous of a tenderness the war has already burned out of her own hardened heart. Her jealousy, therefore, curdles fast into open hatred.

The band swells into an army of hundreds, then thousands. Demetrio, once a hunted farmer with a single rifle, is now saluted as General by men who could not say what cause they serve, only that they follow him.

Sensing which way the war is turning, Cervantes urges Camila to travel with the band for her own safety. Therefore she leaves her mother's house and follows him into the fighting, but once fully in his power, his attention quickly, cruelly cools.

One drunken night, deep in captured territory, Cervantes forces himself on Camila. She weeps but stays, having nowhere left to go and no one to protect her, therefore shame binds her ever tighter to the very man who has wronged her.

La Pintada's jealousy curdles into fury; in a violent quarrel over Cervantes, she draws a blade and stabs Camila to death. Therefore the one soul who joined this war for love, not plunder, becomes the first it truly kills among its own.

Demetrio does nothing to punish the killing, violence inside his own ranks has become unremarkable to him by now, therefore the band that once fought only federal soldiers preys on itself almost as easily as it preys on the enemy it was formed to fight.

Unshaken by Camila's death, Cervantes quietly gathers gold, jewelry, and silver skimmed from the campaign's endless plunder, therefore revealing his true war was never the Cause he preached so eloquently, it was always, only, his own private fortune.

When his old wound finally heals and the fighting turns costly, Cervantes deserts a second time, slipping quietly away to the United States with his stolen riches. Therefore the one man who preached the Cause loudest is the first to abandon it entirely.

Demetrio's old friend Anastasio dies in a skirmish that gains nothing at all, one death now among dozens forgotten by morning. Therefore the band's original purpose, defending home, family, dignity, grows harder to remember with every fresh, unmarked grave they leave behind them.

Villa's revolutionary armies begin fighting one another almost as fiercely as they once fought the federales; factions splinter, generals betray generals overnight, therefore Demetrio no longer knows which side, if any, he is truly still serving.

Demetrio briefly returns home; his wife, seeing his new money, rank, and scars, begs him to finally stay now that he has proven himself. But he cannot answer even her simplest question, why he must keep fighting at all.

He tells her it is like a stone thrown down a mountainside: once loosed, it cannot stop itself. Therefore he rides back to the war not for any cause he can name, but because he no longer remembers how to be anything else.

His band, thinned now by desertion, plunder, and death, drifts back toward the same sierra where the novel began, low on ammunition, low on morale, low on men who still remember why they first picked up a rifle.

Scouts warn Demetrio that federal troops are massing in the canyon of Juchipila, the very pass where he once ambushed soldiers as a hunted farmer at the story's start. But, weary past caution now, he leads his men in anyway.

His remaining men sense a trap and urge caution, but Demetrio, fatalistic now and tired of running, pushes forward regardless, therefore the canyon walls that once sheltered him as a fugitive begin closing around him again, this time like a door.

Federal riflemen open fire from the cliffs high above. Demetrio's small band, caught below in the open ravine, falls one by one, with nowhere to run and no reinforcements anywhere near enough to save them now.

Demetrio keeps firing even as his last men die around him, his rifle barrel scalding hot in his hands, his eyes fixed not on the enemy above but on some far, unreachable horizon only he can see.

A final volley cuts him down where he stands. He dies in the same canyon that first made him a rebel, the war that began as one man's self-defense ending, therefore, exactly as it started: with gunfire, and a body in the dust.

News of Demetrio's death barely travels beyond his own valley. Other generals rise, other bands form, other farmers pick up rifles for reasons they, too, will struggle ever to fully explain to themselves.

The revolution rolls on without him, entirely indifferent to the men who die inside it. Therefore Demetrio's story closes not as triumph but as one stone among thousands, thrown down the very same mountainside.

What it means

Azuela's insight is unsparing: revolutions can devour the very people who ignite them, rewarding cold opportunists like Cervantes with fortune and safety while burying the sincere, like Demetrio and Camila, inside the same violence they once hoped would finally set them free.

🎧 Read-along audio is being prepared — text-only for now.

The Underdogs
0:000:00

Reader rating

Not rated yet

Reader comments

The Underdogs by Mariano Azuela (#749) · booooooks